Increase in CT Scans Seen in Emergency Departments

If the growth trend continues, by 2011, almost 20% of all emergency department (ED) visits may involve a CT exam.

The study's findings were presented at the annual meeting of the Radiological Society of North America (RSNA), held November 28 to December 3, 2010 in Chicago, IL, USA, and published online in November 2010 and in the journal Radiology. "It is not surprising that CT utilization has increased,” said lead researcher David B. Larson, MD, MBA, director of quality improvement in the department of radiology at Cincinnati Children's Hospital Medical Center (OH,USA). "What's surprising is the sustained high rate of that growth. However, recent developments, such as increased awareness of cost, radiation concerns, national health care reform legislation and the economic recession, are likely to inhibit further growth.”

The investigators used data collected by the US National Hospital Ambulatory Medical Care Survey from 1995 through 2007 to identify nationwide trends associated with CT utilization in the ED. The researchers performed statistic analysis on a mean of 30,044 ED visits from each year over the 13-year period to estimate overall usage of CT in the ED. "We have seen a remarkable growth in CT utilization, not only in the number of ED visits that involve CT imaging but in the percentage of patients walking into the ED that receive a CT,” Dr. Larson noted.

According to the analysis, the number of ED visits that included a CT exam increased from 2.7 million in 1995 to 16.2 million in 2007, a 5.9-fold increase, and an average growth rate of 16% per year. The percentage of ED visits involving a CT exam increased from 2.8% in 1995 to 13.9% in 2007. "CT is a wonderful technique that is widely available,” Dr. Larson said. "Over the 13 years in our study, image resolution improved significantly, making CT a great tool to look for kidney stones, appendicitis, and coronary artery disease.”

For much of the 13-year period studied, headache was the complaint most commonly associated with a CT exam in the ED. But by 2007, headache was surpassed by abdominal pain as the complaint most frequently associated with CT imaging. In 2007, patients with abdominal pain represented 12.8% of all ED visits involving CT.

CT exams to investigate abdominal pain have a higher radiation dose than CT exams used to determine the cause of a headache. The study revealed that, overall, the use of CT for complaints that are usually related to exams with a higher radiation dose grew faster than those typically related to exams with a lower radiation dose. This suggests that the radiation dose associated with CT in the ED may be growing at a faster rate than the growth in the overall use of CT.

In 1995, a patient visiting the ED with chest pain rarely received a CT exam. However, by 2007, chest pain was the third most typical complaint in the ED associated with CT imaging. "Our emphasis now should be on carefully evaluating the use of CT in specific situations and making sure it is used appropriately,” Dr. Larson said.

Related Links:
Cincinnati Children's Hospital Medical Center