We use cookies to understand how you use our site and to improve your experience. This includes personalizing content and advertising. To learn more, click here. By continuing to use our site, you accept our use of cookies. Cookie Policy.

Features Partner Sites Information LinkXpress hp
Sign In
Advertise with Us
ARAB HEALTH - INFORMA

Download Mobile App




Artificial Intelligence Could Challenge Role of Doctors

By HospiMedica International staff writers
Posted on 22 Nov 2018
Print article
Artificial intelligence (AI) systems, which simulate human intelligence by learning, reasoning, and self-correction, have the potential to be more accurate than doctors at making diagnoses and performing surgical interventions, according to a new study.

Researchers at the Swiss Federal Institute of Technology (ETH; Zurich, Switzerland), McGill Institute for Health and Social Policy (IHSP; Montréal, Canada), and University Hospital Zürich (USZ; Switzerland) met to raise the question of whether machines will ever completely replace doctors. Their opinions were published on November 7, 2018, in BMJ.

According to Jörg Goldhahn, MD, of ETH, the answer is yes. AI has a near unlimited capacity for data processing and subsequent learning, and can do this at a speed that humans cannot match. In addition, it is not subject to the potential bias seen in human learning due to cultural influences and links with particular institutions. And while the ability to form relationships with patients is often presented as an argument in favor of human doctors, Goldhahn suggests that this may also be their Achilles heel. Trust is important to patients, but machines and systems can be more trustworthy than humans if they can be regarded as unbiased and without conflicts of interest.

“The notion that today's physicians could approximate this knowledge by keeping abreast of current medical research while maintaining close contacts with their patients is an illusion, not least because of the sheer volume of data,” concluded Dr. Goldhahn. “Introducing AI-driven systems could be cheaper than hiring and training new staff. They are also universally available, and can even monitor patients remotely. Doctors as we now know them will become obsolete eventually.”

But co-authors Vanessa Rampton, PhD, Branco Weiss fellow at IHSP, and Professor Giatgen Spinas, MD, of University Hospital Zürich, disagree. They maintain that machines will never replace doctors entirely, because the inter-relational quality of the doctor-patient relationship is vital and cannot be replicated. While they concur that AI will increasingly be able to perform tasks that humans do today, doctors are better at dealing with the patient as a whole person. Doctors can relate to the patient as a fellow human being, building a relationship that takes into account an individual patient's preferences, values, and social circumstances.

“Computers aren't able to care for patients in the sense of showing devotion or concern for the other as a person, because they are not people and do not care about anything. Sophisticated robots might show empathy as a matter of form, just as humans might behave nicely in social situations, yet remain emotionally disengaged because they are only performing a social role,” said Dr. Rampton and Professor Spinas. “Feeling they've been heard by someone who understands the seriousness of the problem and whom they can trust can be crucial for patients.”

“Most importantly there will be no cure for some patients; care will be about helping them have the best quality of life possible with their condition and for the longest time. Here doctors are irreplaceable. Robots cannot understand our concern with relating illness to the task of living a life,” they concluded. “As the Harvard professor Francis Peabody observed in 1927, the task of the doctor is to transform ‘that case of mitral stenosis in the second bed on the left’ into the complex problem of ‘Henry Jones, lying awake nights while he worries about his wife and children’.”

Related Links:
Swiss Federal Institute of Technology
McGill Institute for Health and Social Policy
University Hospital Zürich

Gold Member
POC Blood Gas Analyzer
Stat Profile Prime Plus
New
Gold Member
X-Ray QA Meter
T3 AD Pro
New
Pneumatic Stool
Avante 5-Leg Pneumatic Stool
New
Mobile Barrier
Tilted Mobile Leaded Barrier

Print article

Channels

Critical Care

view channel
Image: The UbiqVue 2A Multiparameter System is based around a wearable ciosensor with chest-based SpO2 (Photo courtesy of LifeSignals)

Multiparameter System Featuring Wearable Biosensor Enables Continuous, Near Real-Time Patient Monitoring

A novel cloud-based system featuring a wearable biosensor with chest-based SpO2 monitoring enables continuous patient monitoring across both hospital and out-of-hospital care settings. The UbiqVue 2A... Read more

Surgical Techniques

view channel
Image: The Toumai system has successfully completed over 200 human robotic telesurgery cases globally (Photo courtesy of MicroPort Medbot)

Surgical Robot System with Telesurgery Capability to Revolutionize Healthcare Delivery

Robotic telesurgery, or remote surgery, is a technique where a surgeon operates on a patient from a distance using a robot and telecommunication networks. This approach allows surgeons to conduct procedures... Read more

Patient Care

view channel
Image: The portable biosensor platform uses printed electrochemical sensors for the rapid, selective detection of Staphylococcus aureus (Photo courtesy of AIMPLAS)

Portable Biosensor Platform to Reduce Hospital-Acquired Infections

Approximately 4 million patients in the European Union acquire healthcare-associated infections (HAIs) or nosocomial infections each year, with around 37,000 deaths directly resulting from these infections,... Read more

Point of Care

view channel
Image: The acoustic pipette uses sound waves to test for biomarkers in blood (Photo courtesy of Patrick Campbell/CU Boulder)

Handheld, Sound-Based Diagnostic System Delivers Bedside Blood Test Results in An Hour

Patients who go to a doctor for a blood test often have to contend with a needle and syringe, followed by a long wait—sometimes hours or even days—for lab results. Scientists have been working hard to... Read more
Copyright © 2000-2024 Globetech Media. All rights reserved.